Colorectal cancer screening: FIT for purpose?

“The COLONPREV trial—published online in The Lancet—is, therefore, a landmark study. It is the first randomised controlled trial to compare colorectal cancer deaths in people screened with the two most commonly used methods: colonoscopy and faecal immunochemical test (FIT), an antibody-based test for haemoglobin, indicative of blood in the stool. The study finds that invitation to biennial FIT-based screening is non-inferior to invitation to one-time colonoscopy in terms of colorectal cancer mortality at 10 years. These results build on the NordICC trial, published in The New England Journal of Medicine, which showed that invitation to colonoscopy reduced colorectal cancer risk … Read More

The need to call out corporate corruption in health

“The tobacco and ultra-processed food industries exemplify the detrimental effects of corporate influence on public health. For decades, tobacco companies lobbied aggressively against health regulations, contributing to millions of preventable deaths worldwide. Despite still causing more than 8 million tobacco-related deaths annually, the tobacco industry now claims through its public-relations campaigns and selective science that it focuses on “harm reduction”, particularly by selling new products such as e-cigarettes. These tactics allow the industry to argue that it deserves a seat at the policy table, all while shifting to new types of addictive and harmful products, targeting youth, and continuing to oppose tobacco … Read More

Optimizing placement of public-access naloxone kits using geospatial analytics: a modelling study

“We compared public-access naloxone strategies using more than 14 000 cases of opioid poisoning in Metro Vancouver over a 6-year period. We found that the 647 take-home naloxone sites were within a 3-minute walk to more than one-third of all opioid poisonings and had high coverage efficiency (Table 2) [the top five location categories for coverage efficiency were: government office, take-home naloxone site, convenience store, retail store and pharmacy]. In addition to existing operations that distribute take-home naloxone kits, which are likely taken elsewhere, take-home naloxone site locations appear generally well-aligned with where opioid poisonings occur, so they are also … Read More

State Medical Boards and Interstate Telemedicine in the Courtroom

“Despite the convenience and value of telehealth, many states have rolled back COVID-19 pandemic–era flexibilities and reimposed strict licensure requirements for telemedicine. Thus, as it was prepandemic, so it is again that a physician, duly licensed in their home state, is prohibited from consulting or following up with an out-of-state patient via video or phone unless they are also licensed in the patient’s state. Penalties for doing so without that license can amount to tens of thousands of dollars in fines and potential imprisonment. Despite growing pressure to respond to patient preferences and widespread evidence of the benefits of interstate … Read More

Doing more cancer screening won’t reduce Black-white health disparities

“Why would more screening in both Black and white Americans reduce the mortality disparity between the two groups? What’s more, cancer screening actually stands out for its lack of racial disparity. The proportion of Black and white women having mammograms has been virtually identical for the past three decades (in fact, Black women currently have the test at slightly higher rates). Yet deaths from breast cancer are about one-third higher in Black women. For the past two decades, a similar pattern has been seen in colorectal cancer screening — equal rates among Black and white Americans — yet colorectal cancer … Read More

Different reasonable methodological choices can lead to vastly different estimates of the economic burden of diseases

“Landeiro and colleagues computed the economic burden of four diseases (cancer, coronary heart disease [CHD], dementia, and stroke) in England using consistent methodology and a broad definition of disease burden. This analysis is an important advance that will allow policy makers, researchers, and other stakeholders to assess the absolute and relative burden of these diseases in a meaningful way. The Global Burden of Disease also uses a consistent methodology for estimating the burden of many diseases across countries. However, its methodology focuses only on mortality and morbidity, which are evaluated comprehensively, but does not account for many other costs included … Read More

Dollars and Sense: The Cost of Cancer Screening in the United States

“Colonoscopy is the dominant approach to colorectal cancer screening in the United States. Among people who are screened, two thirds get a colonoscopy. This fact is easy to miss in Halpern and colleagues’ 2021 data, which included 9.2 million people reporting colonoscopy and 9.8 million reporting fecal immunochemical testing (FIT). That ambiguity is explained by the distinct screening intervals (every 10 years for colonoscopy and annually for FIT), whereas there is no ambiguity about the difference in the resources required each year: $24 billion for colonoscopy versus $0.6 billion for FIT. Colonoscopy is clearly overused in the United States. It … Read More

With End of Affirmative Action, a Push for a New Tool: Adversity Scores

“Over the years, medical schools have made some progress in diversifying their student bodies, with numbers ticking up. But just like undergraduate admissions, wealth and connections continue to play a determining role in who is accepted. More than half of medical students come from families in the top 20 percent of income, while only 4 percent come from those in the bottom 20 percent, according to data from the Association of American Medical Colleges. There is also a family dynamic. Children of doctors are 24 times more likely to become doctors than their peers, according to the American Medical Association. … Read More

Providing Birth Control Over the Counter Should Be Just the Beginning

“At a 1992 conference on birth control, an official on the F.D.A.’s fertility and maternal health drugs advisory committee, Philip Corfman, noted that the birth control pill is safer than aspirin, which is available over the counter. The F.D.A. subsequently announced plans to convene a hearing to consider moving oral contraceptives over-the-counter. It was believed that this would greatly expand access to birth control by bypassing doctors, to whom millions of Americans then — as still now — had little access. But, as the historian Heather Munro Prescott has recounted, the hearing was canceled at least partly because of criticism from … Read More

Using Publicly Available Health Plan Pricing Data For Research And App Development

“We used Elevance Health’s in-network pricing data and medical claims data. We focused on in-network prices because these are the prices negotiated by the payer, and out-of-network providers represent a small percentage of use for planned procedures. The formatting of the released data files follows the specifications provided by CMS. We limited our analysis to one state, Colorado, and one month, August 2022, to illustrate the concepts. [..] We split the prices into two components, the professional price and the facility price. Notably, these two components may not be the only costs associated with a procedure as there are often other … Read More